Tag Archives: AndroidPerformance

Optimize for Android Go : Lessons from Google apps Part 2

Posted by Niharika Arora, Developer Relations Engineer

Building for Android Go involves paying special attention to performance optimizations and resource usage.

In part-1 of this blog, we discussed why developers should consider building for Android Go, some tips on optimizing the app memory and identified the standard approach to follow while fixing performance issues. In this blog, we will talk about the other vitals to pay attention to while building apps for Android Go.

Optimize your apps for Android Go

Improve startup latency

Improving app startup time requires a deep understanding of things that affect it.

  • Avoid eager initialization: Avoid doing eager work that may not be needed in your app’s startup sequence. The user launching your app is the most well-known reason a process starts, but WorkManager, JobScheduler, BroadcastReceiver, bound Services, and ContentProviders can also start your app process in the background. Avoid initializing things eagerly in your Application class like ContentProviders, or androidx initializers if possible (If they are not needed for any possible reason for your app process to start).
  • Move the tasks from UI thread to background thread

    • Identify operations which occupy large time frames and can be optimized.
    • Identify operations that consume more time than expected.
    • Identify operations which cause the main thread to be blocked.

If there are tasks which are taking longer and blocking the main thread, try to move them to a background thread or prefer using WorkManager
    • Check third party library initialization 
Lazy load third party libraries. A lot of libraries do have on demand initialization or disabling auto init options.
      • Check rendering time of webp / png images
        • Prefer webp images over jpg/png
        • Prefer svg for small icons.
        • Check if any layouts are invisible, but still spend time for the images to be loaded.
        • Explore using a low resolution image according to the memory capabilities of the device.
        • Remove unnecessary backgrounds/alpha from views.
    • Avoid synchronous IPCs on UI thread: Check for binder transactions keeping the main thread busy: Often there are multiple Inter process communication happening within the app. These could be anything like image / asset loading, third party libs loading, heavy work on application’s main thread like disk or network access etc. StrictMode is a useful developer tool to detect such accident usage.
    Identify and measure these transactions to understand :
        • How much time does this take and if it is expected & necessary ?
        • Is the main thread sleeping / idle / blocked during this time ? If yes, this could be a performance bottleneck.
        • Can this be delayed ?
    • Wisely use XML and Json parsing: The Gboard app optimized file list parsing by using Java code instead of XML parsing as they were parsing them out into memory as Java objects at runtime. So, GBoard did a work to convert all the XML into Java code at compile time, the latency then become time of class loading, which is much more faster, almost of previous. Benchmarking both XML and Json parsing for your app to identify the appropriate library to be used.
    • Analyze and fix severe disk read contention: To capture this, use StrictMode in your development environment.
      • Detects accidental disk or network access on the application's main thread, where UI operations are received and animations take place.
      • Can automatically terminate the app (or log it to logcat), when a violation has occurred by adding different penalties.

    Optimize app size

    Users often avoid downloading apps that seem too large, particularly in emerging markets where devices connect to spotty 2G and 3G networks with low bandwidth speed or work on pay-by-the-byte plans.

    • Remove unnecessary layouts: Gboard and Camera from Google teams validated the layouts which were unused or could be merged with small UI changes and removed the unnecessary layouts reducing overall app code size.
    • Migrate to dynamic layouts/views when appropriate: The apps deep dive and find out the layouts and views which can be dynamically rendered. They used merge and viewstub to further optimize their views and layouts.
    • Revaluate features with low DAU. Try to disable features which take more memory and make the app less performant: The team further analyzed their apps to specifically optimize for Android Go and disabled features on go devices which were not of much usage but were taking a lot of memory. They removed complex animations, large GIFs etc. to make space for parts of the app.
    • Try combine native binaries with common dependencies into one: If the app has different JNI implementations with a lot of common underlying dependencies - all the different binaries add up to the apk size with redundant components. Camera from Google app benefited from combining several JNI binaries into a single JNI binary while keeping the Java and JNI files separate. This helped the app reduce the apk size by several Mbs.
    • Try to reduce dalvik code size: Check for code that is never used at runtime, eg) large classes and auto-generated code.
      • Code optimizers like ProGuard () could help optimize and shrink code size, but they can't deal with codes guarded by runtime-constants. Replacing the check/flags with compile-time constants to make most usage of the optimization tools.
      • Reduce translatable strings size :
      a.    Don’t translate internal-only UI strings. Mark them as translatable = “false”. 
        
      b.    Remove unused alternative resources: You can use the Android Gradle plugin's resConfigs property to remove alternative resource files that your app does not need. if you are using a library that includes language resources (such as AppCompat or Google Play Services), then your app includes all translated language strings for the messages in those libraries whether the rest of your app is translated to the same languages or not. If you'd like to keep only the languages that your app officially supports, you can specify those languages using the resConfig property. Any resources for languages not specified are removed. 
       
      The following snippet shows how to limit your language resources to just English and French

        android {
            defaultConfig {
                ...
                resConfigs "en", "fr"
            }
        }

        You can read more here.

        c.    Don’t translate what doesn’t need translation: If the string does not participate in a UI, it should not be translated. Strings for the purpose of debugging, exception messages, URLs and so on should be string literals in code, not resources. 
        i.    Don’t translate what’s not shown to the user anyway
        It’s possible to have a String resource that’s practically never shown to the user, but is still strongly referenced. One example is in your <activity>, if you have an android:label set and referencing a String resource but the Activity’s label is never actually shown (e.g. it’s not a launcher Activity and it doesn’t have an app bar that shows its own label).
          
         d.    Don’t translate URLs:  Consider this example:
         

        <string name="car_frx_device_incompatible_sol_message">

        This device doesn\'t support Android Auto.\n

        <a href="https://support.google.com/androidauto/answer/6395843">Learn more</a>

        </string>

         
        You may recognize < and > - these are escape characters for “<” and “>”. They’re needed here because if you were to put an <a> tag inside a <string> tag, then the Android resource compiler would just drop them (as it does with all tags it doesn’t recognize).

        However, this means that you’re translating the HTML tags and the URL to 78 languages. Totally unnecessary.

        Instead, remove the part with HTML:

        <string name="car_frx_device_incompatible_sol_message">

        This device doesn\'t support Android Auto.

        </string>

         
        Note we don’t define a separate string for “Learn more”, because it’s a common string. To produce the HTML snippet for the link, we define "<a href="https://support.google.com/androidauto/answer/6395843>%s</a>" as a string literals in code, and then drop the value of “Learn more” from resources into the format specifier.
         
        e.    Inline untranslated stringsBy specifying strings in strings.xml you can leverage the Android framework to automatically change the actual value used at runtime based on the current configuration (e.g. based on the current locale, show a localized value for the string).    
         
        f.    Remove duplicate stringsIf you have the same string multiple times as a literal in code (“Hello World”), it will be shared across all instances. But resources don’t work this way - if you have an identical string under a different name then unless both are translated identically across 78 languages (unlikely) you’ll end up with duplicates.

        Don’t have duplicate strings!  

        g.    Don’t have separate strings for ALL CAPS or Title Case: Android has built-in support for case mutations. 

        Use android:capitalize (since API level 1). If set, specifies that this TextView has a textual input method and should automatically capitalize what the user types. The default is "none".

          • Reducing asset size: Be mindful of different target device form factors that your app supports and adjust your assets accordingly.
          • Upload your app with Android app bundles: The easiest way to gain immediate app size savings when publishing to Google Play is by uploading your app as an Android App Bundle, which is a new upload format that includes all your app’s compiled code and resources, but defers APK generation and signing to Google Play. Read more here.
          • Utilize dynamic delivery feature if applicable: Play Feature Delivery uses advanced capabilities of app bundles, allowing certain features of your app to be delivered conditionally or downloaded on demand. You can use feature modules for custom delivery. A unique benefit of feature modules is the ability to customize how and when different features of your app are downloaded onto devices running Android 5.0 (API level 21) or higher. Learn more here.

          Recap

          This part of the blog captures some best practices, recommendations and learnings from Google apps to optimize your app size, startup latency and improve go app experience that helps drive user engagement and adoption for your Android app. In part-3, you will get to know the tools that helped the Google apps identify and fix such performance issues in their app!

          Optimize for Android (Go edition): Lessons from Google apps – Part 1

          Posted by Niharika Arora, Developer Relations Engineer

          The Android operating system brings the power of computing to everyone. This vision applies to all users, including those on entry-level phones that face real constraints across data, storage, memory, and more.
          This was especially important for us to get right because, when we first announced Android (Go edition) back in 2017, people using low-end phones accounted for 57% of all device shipments globally (IDC Mobile Phone Tracker).


          What is Android (Go edition)?

          Android (Go edition) is a mobile operating system built for entry-level smartphones with less RAM. Android (Go edition) runs lighter and saves data, enabling Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) to build affordable, entry-level devices that empower people with possibility. RAM requirements are listed below, and for full Android (Go edition) device capability specifications, see this page on our site.

          Year

          2018

          2019

          2020

          2021

          2022

          2023

          Release

          Android 8

          Android 9

          Android 10

          Android 11

          Android 12

          Android 13

          Min RAM

          512MB

          512MB

          512MB

          1GB

          1GB

          2GB



          Android (Go edition) provides an optimized experience for low-RAM devices. By tailoring the configuration and making key trade-offs, we’re able to improve speed and performance for low-end devices and offer a quality phone experience for more than 250M people around the world.


          Recent Updates

          We are constantly making phones powered by Android (Go edition) more accessible with additional performance optimizations and features designed specifically for new & novice internet users, like translation, app switching, and data saving.

          Below are the recent improvements we made for Android 12:

          Faster App Launches

          Longer Battery Life 

          Easier App Sharing 

          More Privacy Control





          Why build for Android (Go edition)?

          With the fast growing & easily accessible internet, and all the features available at low cost, OEMs and developers are aiming & building their apps specifically for Android (Go edition) devices.

          Fast forward to today — over 250 million+ people worldwide actively use an Android (Go edition) phone. And also considering the big OEMs like Jio, Samsung, Oppo, Realme etc. building Android (Go edition) devices, there is a need for developers to build apps that perform well especially on Go devices.

          But the markets with the fast growing internet and smartphone penetration can have some challenging issues, such as:
          • Your app is not starting within the required time limit.
          • A lot of features/required capabilities increases your app size 
          • How to handle memory pressure while working on Go apps?


          Optimize your apps for Android (Go edition)

          To help your app succeed and deliver the best possible experience in developing markets, we have put together some best practices based on experience building our own Google apps Gboard & Camera from Google.


          Approach

          Define Metrics & breakdowns → Benchmark Metrics → Identify bottlenecks → Optimize bottlenecks → Add regression tests.        ↑_________________________________↓

          Phases

          Description

          DefineBefore starting any optimization effort, it’s important to define the goals. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) have to be defined for the app.
          • KPIs can be common across different apps and some can be very specific. Some examples of KPIs can be  
          KPICategory
          App Startup Latency
          Common to all apps
          App Crash Rate
          Common to all apps
          End to end latency for CUJ - Camera Shot
          Specific to Camera app
          App Not Responding RateCommon to all apps
          • Once KPIs are defined the team should agree on the target thresholds. This can be derived from the minimum user experience/benchmarks in mind.
          • KPIs should ideally be defined from the perspective of balancing User Experience and technical complexity.
          BreakdownOnce KPIs are defined, the next steps could be to break down a given KPI into individual signal metrics.
          • For example → End to end latency for CUJ (shots in Camera) can be divided into → Frame capture latency, image processing latency, time spent on saving a processed image to disk etc.
          • Similarly, App Crash Rate can be bucketed into → Crash due to unhandled errors, Crash due to high memory usage, Crash due to ANR etc.
          BenchmarkBenchmark or measure the KPI values and individual metrics to identify current performance.
          If KPI targets are met, things are good. If not → identify the bottlenecks by looking at the individual breakdowns.
          Repeat the process


          After optimizing a certain bottleneck go back and benchmark the metrics again to see if the KPI targets are met. If not, repeat the process. If yes, great job!
          Add Regular regression testThat either runs for every change or in some frequency to identify regressions in KPIs. It is more difficult to debug and find sources of regressions or bugs than to not allow them to get into the codebase. Don’t allow the changes that fail the KPI goals unless the decision is to update the KPI targets.
          • Try to invest in building a regression infrastructure to deal with such issues in early stages.
          • Decide on how often tests should run? What should be the optimal frequency for your app?



          Optimize App Memory

          GBoard used the onTrimMemory() signal to trim unneeded memory while it goes in the background and there is not enough memory to keep as many background processes running as desired, for example, trimming unneeded memory usage from expressions, search, view cache or openable extensions in background. It helped them reduce the number of times being low memory killed and the average background RSS. Resident Set Size(RSS) is basically the portion of memory occupied by your app process that is held in main memory (RAM). To know more about RSS, please refer here. 
          • Check if malloc can be replaced with mmap when accessing read-only & large files: mmap is only recommended for reading a large file onto memory ('read-only memory mapped file'). The kernel has some special optimizations for read-only memory mapped files, such as unloading unused pages.
          Typically this is useful for loading large assets or ML models.
          • Scheduling tasks which require similar resources(CPU, IO, Memory) appropriately: Concurrent scheduling could lead to multiple memory intensive operations to run in parallel and leading to them competing for resources and exceeding the peak memory usage of the app. The Camera from Google app found multiple problems, ensured a cap to peak memory and further optimized their app by appropriately allocating resources, separating tasks into CPU intensive, low latency tasks(tasks that need to be finished fast for Good UX) & IO tasks. Schedule tasks in right thread pools / executors so they can run on resource constrained devices in a balanced fashion.
          • Find & fix memory leaks: Fighting leaks is difficult but there are tools like Android Studio Memory Profiler/Perfetto specifically available to reduce the effort to find and fix memory leaks.
          Google apps used the tools to identify and fix memory issues which helped reduce the memory usage/footprint of the app. This reduction allowed other components of the app to run without adding additional memory pressure on the system.

          An example from Gboard app is about View leaks
          A specific case is caching subviews, like this: 
           

          void onKeyboardViewCreated(View keyboardView) {
            this.keyButtonA = keyboardView.findViewById(...);
            ...
          }
           

          The |keyboardView| might be released at some time, and the |keyButtonA| should be assigned as null appropriately at some time to avoid the view leak.

          Lessons learned:
            • Always add framework/library updates after analyzing the changes and verifying its impact early on.
            • Make sure to release memory before assigning new value to a pointer pointing to other object allocation in heap in Java. (native backend java objects) 
          For example :
          In Java it should be ok to do
           

          ClassA obj = new ClassA("x");
          // ... something
          obj = new ClassB("y");

           
          GC should clean this up eventually.
           
          if ClassA allocates native resources underneath and doesn't cleanup automatically on finalize(..) and requires caller to call some release(..)  method, it needs to be like this 
           

          ClassA obj = new ClassA("x");
          // ... something

          // Explicit cleanup.
          obj.release();

          obj = new ClassB("y");

           
          else it will leak native heap memory. 
          • Optimize your bitmaps: Large images/drawables usually consume more memory in the app. Google apps identified and optimized large bitmaps that are used in their apps. 
          Lessons learned :
            • Prefer Lazy/on-demand initializations of big drawables.
            • Release view when necessary.
            • Avoid using full colored bitmaps when possible. 
          For example: Gboard’s glide typing feature needs to show an overlay view with a bitmap of trails, which can only has the alpha channel and apply a color filter for rendering.
           

          // Creating the bitmap for trails.

          trailBitmap = Bitmap.createBitmap(w, h, Bitmap.Config.ALPHA_8);

          ...

          // Setup paint for trails.

          trailPaint.setColorFilter(new ColorMatrixColorFilter(new ColorMatrix(new float[] {

            0, 0, 0, 0, (color >> 16) & 0xFF,

            0, 0, 0, 0, (color >> 8) & 0xFF,

            0, 0, 0, 0, color & 0xFF,

            0, 0, 0, 1, 0

          })));

          ...

          // onDraw

          @Override

          protected void onDraw(Canvas canvas) {

            super.onDraw(canvas);

            if (trailBitmap != null) {

              canvas.drawBitmap(trailBitmap, 0, 0, trailPaint);

            }

          }

           
          A screenshot of glide typing on Gboard
          • Check and only set the alpha channel for the bitmap for complex custom views used in the app. This saved them a couple of MBs (per screen size/density).
          • While using Glide, 
            • The ARGB_8888 format has 4 bytes/pixel consumption while RGB_565 has 2 bytes/pixel. Memory footprint gets reduced to half when RGB_565 format is used but using lower bitmap quality comes with a price too. Whether you need alpha values or not, try to fit your case accordingly.
            • Configure and use cache wisely when using a 3P lib like Glide for image rendering.
          • Try to choose other options for GIFs in your app when building for Android (Go edition) as GIFs take a lot of memory.
          • The aapt tool can optimize the image resources placed in res/drawable/ with lossless compression during the build process. For example, the aapt tool can convert a true-color PNG that does not require more than 256 colors to an 8-bit PNG with a color palette. Doing so results in an image of equal quality but a smaller memory footprint. Read more here.
          • You can reduce PNG file sizes without losing image quality using tools like pngcrush, pngquant, or zopflipng. All of these tools can reduce PNG file size while preserving the perceptive image quality.
          • You could use resizable bitmaps. The Draw 9-patch tool is a WYSIWYG editor included in Android Studio that allows you to create bitmap images that automatically resize to accommodate the contents of the view and the size of the screen. Learn more about the tool here

          Recap

          This part of the blog outlines why developers should consider building for Android (Go edition), a standard approach to follow while optimizing their apps and some recommendations & learnings from Google apps to improve their app memory and appropriately allocate resources.

          In the next part of this blog, we will talk about the best practices on Startup latency, app size and the tools used by Google apps to identify and fix performance issues.